Addressing Underperformance: A Leader’s Guide
Image credits: airfocus / Unsplash
As a Leader or Manager, addressing an employee who isn’t meeting expectations is one of the most challenging yet crucial conversations you'll face. How you handle this can significantly impact team morale, productivity, and the individual's future performance. Here’s a comprehensive guide to navigating this delicate conversation effectively:
Identify the Misalignment Before initiating the conversation, pinpoint where expectations are diverging. Reflect on whether the employee understands the performance standards and the potential consequences of not meeting them. Clear communication of expectations is fundamental.
Schedule a Private Meeting Choose a private, distraction-free setting for this discussion. This ensures confidentiality and minimises stress. Avoid public or high-stress times for these conversations.
Initiate with a Self-Evaluation Begin the meeting by asking the employee to assess their performance. This self-evaluation can reveal their awareness of the issues and provide a foundation for a more balanced discussion.
Provide Specific Examples Be prepared with concrete examples of where performance has fallen short. General feedback can be confusing; specific instances help clarify the areas needing improvement.
Connect Performance to Goals Tie the conversation back to the employee's professional goals. Show how their current performance impacts their ability to achieve these aspirations and the broader organisational objectives.
Explain the "Why" Clarify why their role is vital to the team and the company’s success. Understanding their impact on the larger mission can be a powerful motivator for improvement.
Set Clear Expectations Conclude the conversation with explicit expectations and actionable steps. Ensure there’s no ambiguity about what “meeting expectations” looks like moving forward.
Develop an Improvement Plan Together Collaborate on a plan of action. Whether it’s a performance improvement plan or regular updates, involve the employee in crafting this roadmap. This inclusion can foster ownership and commitment to the improvement process.
Schedule Regular Follow-Ups Regular check-ins are essential to monitor progress and provide ongoing support. Adjust the frequency based on the severity of the performance issues and the employee's progress.
Document the Conversation Thorough documentation is crucial. It serves as a reference for future discussions and provides clarity on agreed actions and expectations.
By following these steps, leaders can transform a difficult conversation into a constructive dialogue, fostering growth and improvement. Remember, the goal is not just to address the current performance issues but to support the employee’s development and align their efforts with the organisation's success.
